diff --git a/ShareX/Forms/MainForm.cs b/ShareX/Forms/MainForm.cs
index 291b570c5..a7883fab0 100644
--- a/ShareX/Forms/MainForm.cs
+++ b/ShareX/Forms/MainForm.cs
@@ -588,7 +588,7 @@ private static void SetEnumChecked(Enum value, params ToolStripDropDownItem[] pa
 
         private void UpdateImageEffectsMenu(ToolStripDropDownItem parent)
         {
-            int indexAddImageEffects = (int)AfterCaptureTasks.AddImageEffects - 1;
+            int indexAddImageEffects = AfterCaptureTasks.AddImageEffects.GetIndex() - 1;
             ToolStripMenuItem tsmiAddImageEffects = (ToolStripMenuItem)parent.DropDownItems[indexAddImageEffects];
             tsmiAddImageEffects.DropDownItems.Clear();