diff --git a/ShareX/TaskHelpers.cs b/ShareX/TaskHelpers.cs
index 8598cb21b..6ba0ad100 100644
--- a/ShareX/TaskHelpers.cs
+++ b/ShareX/TaskHelpers.cs
@@ -681,7 +681,10 @@ public static void OpenScreenColorPicker(TaskSettings taskSettings = null)
                 if (Program.MainForm.niTray.Visible)
                 {
                     Program.MainForm.niTray.Tag = null;
-                    Program.MainForm.niTray.ShowBalloonTip(3000, "ShareX", string.Format(Resources.TaskHelpers_OpenQuickScreenColorPicker_Copied_to_clipboard___0_, text), ToolTipIcon.Info);
+
+                    //Only show the balloon notification if BalloonTip is selected in settings
+                    if (taskSettings.GeneralSettings.PopUpNotification != PopUpNotificationType.None)
+                        Program.MainForm.niTray.ShowBalloonTip(3000, "ShareX", string.Format(Resources.TaskHelpers_OpenQuickScreenColorPicker_Copied_to_clipboard___0_, text), ToolTipIcon.Info);
                 }
             }
         }